Updated: November 14, 2025 by Michael Kahn. Published: November 14, 2025.
Switching from a gas water heater to an electric heat pump water heater should be straightforward. You’re making an environmentally responsible choice, taking advantage of generous rebates, and reducing your energy bills. At least, that’s what the brochures promise.
Installing a Heat Pump Water Heater isn’t as simple as you’d think or hope for.
The reality involves more paperwork, more requirements, and more unexpected costs than many Sacramento homeowners anticipate.
I learned this firsthand when I decided to replace my 14 year old 40-gallon gas water heater with an 80-gallon AO Smith heat pump water heater in my Sacramento home. The project would cost $13,227, including construction modifications, demo work, and a 12-year parts and labor warranty from Brower Mechanical.
But before we could even start, I had to address an issue I never saw coming: my perfectly functional, advanced Mitsubishi heat pump HVAC system needed a thermostat downgrade to qualify for rebates.
Sacramento residents switching to heat pump water heaters can access substantial financial incentives.
SMUD offers up to $3,000 in rebates for gas-to-electric conversions, with the full amount available for 80-gallon units. The federal government provides a 30% tax credit up to $2,000.
California’s TECH Clean California program adds another $1,100 for single-family homes in Northern California.
On paper, these incentives can reduce your out-of-pocket costs significantly. The challenge lies in meeting the eligibility requirements for each program simultaneously.
SMUD requires working with a contractor from their network. Your heat pump water heater must meet NEEA Tier III or IV requirements for climate zone 12, include a thermostatic mixing valve, and receive proper permits.
TECH Clean California has its own set of rules. You must enroll in a demand response program for three years. You need to be on a time-of-use rate if you’re not already. And your contractor must be TECH-certified.
Here’s where things get complicated. For SMUD customers, the primary demand response option is My Energy Optimizer. To participate in this program, you need an approved smart thermostat connected to Wi-Fi that controls your central air conditioning.
My home uses a modern Mitsubishi SVZ-KP36NA indoor HVAC unit. This system included a wireless interface that provides sophisticated climate control, the REDLink Wireless Interface and MHK2 Controller. The wireless thermostat includes advanced sensors that monitor multiple zones, adjust automatically based on occupancy, and optimize energy usage throughout the day.
These don’t come cheap either – the parts alone will run you almost $600 for this advanced set of technology. Unfortunately, years after using this system, it would suddenly feel like a waste of money.
It’s an excellent system. Unfortunately, it doesn’t qualify for SMUD’s My Energy Optimizer program.
The approved thermostat list includes models from Nest, ecobee, Sensi, and Honeywell that require hardwired connections. My wireless Mitsubishi interface can’t communicate with SMUD’s demand response system.
To qualify for the heat pump water heater rebate through TECH Clean California, I needed to make my HVAC system less advanced and less efficient for the next 3 years.
Brower Mechanical explained the solution. They recommended the ecobee Smart Thermostat Premium, which they found to be most compatible with Mitsubishi heat pump systems. But installing it requires removing the wireless interface, running low-voltage wires from the indoor unit to the thermostat location, and installing a conversion interface called the PAC-445.
The Mitsubishi PAC-445 (technically the PAC-US445CN-1) is a thermostat adapter that allows standard 24-volt thermostats to control Mitsubishi mini-split and heat pump systems. The device connects to the indoor unit through the CN105 connector and requires a field-supplied 24VAC transformer to power the thermostat.
This conversion isn’t plug-and-play. It involves electrical work, mounting hardware, running thermostat wire through walls or attic spaces, and configuring DIP switches on the adapter board.
The PAC-445 works with conventional systems but not true heat pump control. It supports two-stage operation with adjustable and full capacity modes.
For my installation, the combined cost of the PAC-445 adapter, ecobee Smart Thermostat Premium, and professional installation labor came to approximately $1,200.
Let me be clear about the contradiction here. My existing wireless Mitsubishi system optimizes heating and cooling based on real-time conditions throughout my home. It adjusts compressor speed, monitors humidity, and learns usage patterns without any manual intervention.
The ecobee Smart Thermostat Premium is an excellent device with many sophisticated features. It includes radar-based occupancy detection that can sense movement from farther away and even detect breathing.
It monitors indoor air quality, tracking VOCs, humidity, and carbon dioxide levels. It integrates with smart home systems through Alexa, Google Assistant, and Apple HomeKit.
However, connecting the ecobee through the PAC-445 adapter means my HVAC system loses some of its native optimization capabilities. The Mitsubishi system was engineered to work with its proprietary controls.
Adding a third-party thermostat through an adapter creates an extra layer between the thermostat and the heat pump compressor.
The result is likely higher energy consumption from my HVAC system. Yet I’m required to make this change to participate in a program designed to reduce energy use.
Working with Brower Mechanical made the process manageable and slightly less stressful. This Sacramento-based company specializes in heat pumps, electrification projects, and home performance upgrades throughout the greater Sacramento area. As a Mitsubishi Electric Diamond Elite Contractor, they have specific expertise with these systems.
Plus, they were the ones who installed the Mitsubishi heat pump HVAC. What can I say, I like spending tens of thousands of dollars with them.
Their experience proved valuable when addressing the practical challenges of the installation. The 80-gallon AO Smith heat pump water heater is physically larger than my old gas unit.
Heat pump water heaters need substantial air volume to function properly, typically requiring 450 to 700 cubic feet of space with adequate ventilation. The unit also needs specific clearances for service access and proper airflow.
Meeting current building codes required additional construction and demolition work. Sacramento County requires permits for water heater installations. For heat pump water heaters specifically, permits in Sacramento County cost $300.
The AO Smith ProLine XE Voltex 80-gallon model delivers an 84-gallon first hour rating. With a Uniform Energy Factor up to 3.45, it operates at significantly higher efficiency than standard electric or gas water heaters.
The unit can reduce water heating costs by up to 73% compared to conventional electric technology.
The system offers multiple operating modes.
Heat pump mode maximizes efficiency.
Hybrid mode balances efficiency with recovery speed, using heat pump technology as the primary heating method and activating electric elements during high demand periods.
Electric mode uses only the heating elements. Vacation mode reduces energy use when you’re away.
At 51 decibels, the unit operates quietly. The 10-year limited warranty on tank and parts provides long-term protection.
The CoreGard anode rod, Blue Diamond glass lining, and DynaClean sediment-cleaning system help extend the water heater’s lifespan.
My total project cost of $13,227 includes the water heater unit, installation labor, construction modifications, demolition, permits, and the 12-year parts and labor warranty from Brower Mechanical.
The thermostat conversion added another $1,200 for the PAC-445 adapter, ecobee Smart Thermostat Premium, and installation labor.
That’s a total of $14,427.
After applying all available rebates and tax credits, the net cost drops considerably. The SMUD rebate of $3,000, TECH Clean California incentive of $1,800, and federal tax credit of approximately $2,000 (based on 30% of remaining costs) provide substantial savings.
Accessing these incentives requires navigating multiple application processes, working with approved contractors, enrolling in demand response programs, and making system modifications that may not improve overall household energy efficiency.
If you’re considering a similar upgrade, understand that the process involves more than swapping one appliance for another.
Research the specific requirements for each rebate program before starting your project. Confirm that your existing HVAC system is compatible with the thermostats approved for demand response programs. Factor in the cost of any necessary modifications to your HVAC controls if you’re using a newer unit.
Ask your contractor for a detailed breakdown of all costs, including permits, construction work, and any required system changes beyond the water heater installation itself. This particular projected served as a great learning lesson for both myself and Brower.
Verify that they’re certified with all relevant rebate programs. Brower Mechanical handles the paperwork for SMUD rebates and works with TECH Clean California contractors, which simplified the administrative burden.
Consider the three-year commitment required for demand response program enrollment. During demand response events, SMUD can adjust your thermostat settings to reduce grid strain during peak usage periods.
While participation includes incentives like a $50 enrollment bonus and $25 end-of-summer payment, you should understand how these adjustments might affect your comfort.
Budget time for the entire process. Obtaining permits, scheduling inspections, coordinating thermostat modifications, and completing the water heater installation takes longer than a simple appliance replacement.
My project will require multiple site visits and careful coordination between different aspects of the work. Initial bid, plus the bids from other contractors. Multiple back and forth in hammering out details. Two visits to install the wired thermostat. A pre-site visit. Installation, over 2 days.
The push toward home electrification serves important environmental goals. Heat pump water heaters are genuinely more efficient than gas alternatives.
The rebate programs make these upgrades more affordable for homeowners who might not otherwise be able to make the switch.
But the path to electrification shouldn’t require homeowners to reduce the efficiency of other systems. Requiring wireless thermostats to be replaced with hardwired models creates unnecessary waste and potential energy increases.
Modern heat pump HVAC systems are designed to work optimally with their native controls. Converting them to use third-party thermostats through adapters may satisfy program requirements while undermining the overall efficiency goals these programs aim to achieve.
Sacramento residents deserve straightforward paths to home improvements that benefit both their households and the environment. When rebate requirements conflict with system efficiency, the programs themselves need refinement.
Until then, homeowners should approach these projects with realistic expectations about the complexity involved.
The end result for my home is worth the effort. I have a high-efficiency water heater that will reduce my gas consumption and lower my environmental impact. But the journey to get there revealed that major home improvements in 2025 involve navigating bureaucratic requirements that don’t always align with technical best practices.
Understanding these realities before you start can help you plan appropriately and avoid the surprises I encountered along the way.

